This article also appeared in the Washington Times on April 18, 2013.

Washington Times masthead


Americans must no longer ignore false realities and double standards that threaten our health and prosperity.

Private sector errors and transgressions generally affect limited numbers of people and ecological values, whereas government actions have far wider impacts, and regulators get away with misrepresentations and behavior that would ensure punishment for corporate executives.

Clinging to antiquated ideas or technologies in free markets will consign companies to oblivion. By contrast, blinding reality often has no effect on government programs, and cloaking policies in rhetoric like environmental protection, social justice, renewable energy or sustainable development can grant them nearly eternal bliss.

These truths are especially self-evident in two assertions that continue rationalizing government powers, programs, expenditures, and harm to people and planet.

The 1970s-era Club of Rome “peak oil” thesis assumes we are rapidly exhausting the oil and natural gas on which modern civilization and living standards depend. However, 3D and 4D seismic, hydraulic fracturing and other technologies have unlocked another century of petroleum, giving us decades to develop new technologies that will not require perpetual subsidies and environmental sacrifices to prop up “renewable” energy technologies.

We may eventually run out of fossil fuels, but only when we exhaust our ability to innovate – or government prohibits innovation and makes even state and private lands and resources off limits.

“Man-made global warming disaster” claims have likewise foundered on rocky shoals of reality. Even as carbon dioxide levels have “soared” to 395 ppm (0.0395% of Earth’s atmosphere), average global temperatures have not budged in 16 years, and hurricanes, tornadoes, floods, droughts and sea level rise have shown no statistically significant variance from century-long averages or fluctuations.

Moreover, “Climategate” and other revelations have demonstrated that United Nations climate change pronouncements are based on computer models that are no more reliable than palm reading; “studies” that were actually environmentalist press releases, student papers and hikers’ anecdotes; and papers by closed cabals of self-interested scientists who jealously guard their raw data, computer codes, methodologies, power, prestige and funding.

And yet, while even the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is finally recognizing the newly emerging “consensus,” the Environmental Protection Agency continues to rely on obsolescent IPCC documents to justify economy-punishing regulations that it claims will prevent CO2 from “endangering” human health and welfare. In the process, EPA ignores extensive science that doesn’t support its “findings” and illegally prevents peer review of its analytical work products, even by the agency’s own Science Advisory Board.

The EPA, White House, Interior and Energy Departments, Fish and Wildlife Service, and other federal agencies also employ oil depletion and climate chaos to rationalize wind, solar, biofuel and other programs; exempt favored programs from environmental laws; and condone job-killing restrictions on coal use, the Keystone XL pipeline, and onshore and offshore drilling.

EPA claims its regulations will save thousands of lives, which it values at $9 million each. However, it unilaterally raised vehicle fuel efficiency mandates to 54.5 mpg by 2020, forcing Americans to travel in cars that are smaller, lighter, less crash-worthy, and likely to injure and kill many more people. It also illegally exposed human test subjects to what it says are lethal doses of diesel engine pollutants, and ignores how its rules raise poor families’ costs of living and force businesses to lay people off.

Unemployment brings poor nutrition, increased stress, and higher rates of heart attacks and strokes, spousal, child, alcohol and drug abuse, suicide, and premature death. This is especially true for older Americans who have lost jobs, end up on welfare, have limited prospects for new full-time work, or must hold several jobs below their skill level and previous salaries, in this anemic, hyper-regulated, hospital Green economy.

Ethanol programs mean millions of acres of farmland must produce energy equivalent to what could come from oil and gas prospects that government has put off-limits. EPA now promotes E15 gasoline (15% ethanol) and demands that refiners blend in “cellulosic” ethanol that does not exist. Even more corn is thus turned into fuel that gets 35% less mileage per gallon than gasoline.

Just to meet current ethanol quotas, Iowa-sized acreage must be planted in corn and nourished with billions of gallons of water and vast amounts of fertilizers and insecticides. Food-to-fuel has tripled corn prices in just eight years, bringing wealth to corn growers but skyrocketing costs to poultry, egg, meat and fish producers, families with hungry children and aid agencies trying to save starving Africans.

“Eco-friendly” wind turbines maim and kill millions of birds and bats every year – eagles, falcons, hawks, whooping cranes and others. But Fish and Wildlife exempts wind turbine operators from protected species laws and helps them hide the gruesome statistics, while other agencies ignore adverse effects on people’s health from incessant turbine noise and flicker.

The examples are legion. It’s fortunate that ruling elites have double standards, or they wouldn’t have any standards at all.

Legislators and regulators would never tolerate such behavior in the private sector. Citizens should no longer tolerate it in our government.


  • Paul Driessen

    Paul Driessen is senior policy advisor for CFACT and author of Cracking Big Green and Eco-Imperialism: Green Power - Black Death.