The COVID-19 pandemic is disproportionately infecting the already chronically ailing fiscal health of Democrat-run states and cities that are least positioned to recover any time soon, if at all.

Former New York state lieutenant governor Richard Ravitch, now a director of the Volcker Alliance, observed that budget ravages of the global financial crisis and years of fiscal denial in 2009 doesn’t compare with the toll that COVID-19 is inflicting on municipal finance because this time, revenue shortfall is horrific. “There’s an enormous loss of revenue going on, and we don’t know how long it will last.”

Massive business shutdowns and huge numbers of people either unemployed or working from home are draining operating budgets and prohibiting existing debt repayments from many vital revenue sources.

Included are sales, income, real estate and gasoline taxes, bridge and tunnel tolls, airport fees, and public transit fares.

After receiving a $3.9 billion federal bailout in May, New York City’s transit authority, the largest in the nation, is now seeking $12 billion more.

And New York state is freezing hiring, pay raises, and new contracts -plus holding back one-fifth of payments that had been earmarked for local governments, health care, K-12 schools and higher education, transit systems, and payments to nonprofits contracted to provide foster care.

The multi-billion-dollar question now is how many municipal bond issuers — states, cities and others — won’t be able to repay investors. By law, states can’t go into bankruptcy, although Arkansas defaulted on its debts in 1933.

Last May, Fairfield, Alabama, a suburb of Birmingham, became the first city to declare bankruptcy since Detroit in 2013.

Some states and cities are doing a lot better than others, and uncoincidentally, the winners and losers tended to occupy opposing sides of the partisan divide.

Barron’s asked Eaton Vance (a major muni investor) to prepare a comparative financial creditworthiness ranking of all 50 states based upon financial and economic data taken from the past fiscal year ending in June 2019.

The assessments for each included debt levels, pension liabilities, health care obligations, and economic metrics.

Eaton Vance then also provided some additional updated data to factor in projected influences of the COVID-19 period which included estimated budget shortfalls, unemployment rates and available rainy day funds.

Barron’s reported that despite the age of the basic data, the results closely tracked each state’s current bond ratings by Moody’s and S&P.

All eight of the top-ranked states had Republican governors.

In scoring order: Idaho had experienced strong revenue growth; Wyoming had the largest rainy day fund; South Dakota combined good reserves and strong budget management; Utah had strong historical job and population growth; Nebraska had the lowest overall debt as percent of GDP; North Dakota had strong reserves; Tennessee had good operations and well-funded pensions; and Iowa had a very low debt burden.

Virginia, with a Democrat governor, followed in ninth place thanks to a resilient economy bolstered by the second-largest federal employment base, with Minnesota, also Democrat, in 10th.

Farthest at the other end of the rankings are Democratic Illinois at the very bottom, along with second worst rated New Jersey.

Moody’s Investors Service analyst Ted Hampton attributes the Illinois triple-B-minus rating – the lowest investment grade – to the state’s large unfunded pension liabilities, a “chronic unpaid bill backlog,” and a pitifully small $4 million rainy day fund.

After recently borrowing $1.2 billion from the Federal Reserve, Illinois has received authorization to borrow $5 billion more. I previously wrote about the state’s long-standing fiscal fiascos in my May 6 column.

Similarly, runner-up for ranking of top fiscal mismanagement disaster, New Jersey, has one of the country’s worst-funded state retirement plan liabilities. In addition, the state’s $421 million rainy day fund – just one percent of its annual revenue – pales in comparison with number one ranked Idaho’s at 11.5%.

Following Illinois and New Jersey (worst to better), are Democrat-run Kentucky (poorly funded pensions), Pennsylvania (weak reserves and employment), Rhode Island (weak reserves and large pension obligations), Connecticut (highest debt per capita), and Louisiana (weak economy but strong pre-pandemic performance).

Moody’s has slapped negative outlooks on muni ratings for four Democrat-run cities since the pandemic began. Las Vegas (rated double-A) and Honolulu (rated double-A-plus) were both hit by losses to tourism. San Francisco (triple-A) and New York (double-A-plus) are experiencing deterioration of their tax bases as businesses and populations leave.

Add losses of businesses and tax revenues to disproportionately Democrat cities that are experiencing the nation’s worst riot and crime-plagued economic and social casualties. Most notable among these are Minneapolis, Manhattan, Portland, Ore., Seattle, Chicago, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Philadelphia, and Washington, D.C.

To be clear, America’s full recovery from covid shutdowns depends upon the economic health and social well-being of all states and cities irrespective of political governance which collectively contribute about 20% of our nation’s gross domestic product. Accordingly, we all have a huge stake in supporting constructive results of this effort.

Nevertheless, the one thing we cannot afford to do is shield states and cities from terrible consequences of their own bad budgetary decisions over past decades.

In fact, the opposite is true.

It’s irresponsible and reckless to take money from America’s taxpayers and use it to save generations of liberal politicians from the consequences of reckless spending.


  • Larry Bell

    CFACT Advisor Larry Bell heads the graduate program in space architecture at the University of Houston. He founded and directs the Sasakawa International Center for Space Architecture. He is also the author of "Climate of Corruption: Politics and Power Behind the Global Warming Hoax."